THE CONSTITUTION OF THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF NIGERIA, 1999: ANALYZING THE QUEST FOR AN AUTOCHTHONOUS CONSTITUTION
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53363/bureau.v4i3.431Keywords:
Constitution, constitutionalism, federalism, autochthony, autochthonous. people-drivenAbstract
Nigeria is a multi-cultural, multi-ethnic and multi-religious country pieced together by the British colonial administration. Although, the country has remained one indivisible and indissoluble entity, the different regions maintain their distinct identities, and work towards varied aspirations. However, the current 1999 constitution of Nigeria, which is a product of the military administration that ruled Nigeria from 1983 to 1999, seems to create a federal system that disregard the diversities of the country and concentrate power in the center (federal government); yet, it purports in its preamble to be a constitution given by the people of Nigeria. Using the doctrinal approach, this paper appraised the claim of the 1999 constitution as a people-driven document against the backdrop of an autochthonous constitution. It found that the 1999 Nigerian constitution (as amended) lacks legitimacy as an autochthonous constitution because of the absence of participation of the people in the constitution-making process, and the fact that it was midwife by an illegal and unconstitutional military government. The paper also identified the features of the constitution that expose the arbitrariness of the military in foisting a constitution on the people of Nigeria without consensus, such as the over-concentration of revenue generating powers and revenue sharing in the center, and neglect of the federating states. The paper concluded that the Nigerian National Assembly should commence the process of making a new autochthonous constitution for the country to overturn the current 1999 constitution. It recommended that the new constitution should decentralize power to the federating states of Nigeria to meet the yearnings of the different regions of Nigeria.
Downloads
References
Adegbite, O.B. (2019). Between Chasms and Contours: Revisiting Constitutional Legitimacy and the Quest for a Progressive Constitutional State in Nigeria. Africa Journal of Comparative Constitutional Law. 77-102.
Afisi, O.T. (2017). Political Pluralism, Nationalism and Cosmopolitanism. Unilag Journal of Politics. 9(2).
Agbiboa, D.E. (2017). Federalism and Group-Based Inequalities in Nigeria. Accounting for Change in Diverse Societies. (Global Center for Pluralism, Canada, March 2017). available at: https://www.pluralism.ca/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Nigeria_EN.pdf (Last accessed 11th September, 2024).
Ahmed, I.K. and Dantata, B.S. (2016). Federalism and National Integration: The Nigerian Experience. Historical Research Papers. 35. 8-13
Amah, E.I. (2016). Federalism, Democracy and Constitutionalism: The Nigerian Experience. Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization. 53. 1-14.
Amah, E.I. (2017). Nigeria—The Search for Autochthonous Constitution. Beijing Law Review. 8. 141-158.
Anyanwu, C.U. Of Sovereignty, Grundnorm, Autochthonous Conference and the Stability of Decolonized Federal State. In Gidado et al (eds.) Constitutional Essay in Honour of Bola Ige. (Enugu: Chenglo Ltd. 2004).
Bhalla, R.S. (1984). Essays in Constitutional Law of Nigeria. (Jos: University Press.
Bulmer, E. (2017). Federalism: International IDEA Constitution-Building Primer 12 (2nd ed. Stockholm, International IDEA).
Edet, J.E., Nabiebu, M., Otu, M.T., Agi, A.U. & Ijiomah, A. (2023). Shaping Public Policy Through Constitutionalism: Nigeria’s Constitutional Development and the Quest for an Autochthonous Constitution. Migration Letters. 20(S8). 1180–1194.
Eresia-Eke, A. (2012). The Contradictions of Constitution-Making in Nigeria. African Research Review. 6(4). 76-92.
Ezeabasili, I.E (2005). International Relations, Concepts, Theories and Analysis. Landmark, Nigeria.
Hedling, N. (2017). The Fundamentals of a Constitution. International IDEA: Constitution Brief. (February, 2). Available at: https://www.idea.int/sites/default/files/publications/the-fundamentals-of-a-constitution.pdf (Last accessed 11th September 2024).
Hornby, A.S. (2015). Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary, 9th Edition (London: Oxford University press.
Igwenyi, B. O. (2019). Modern Constitutional Law in Nigeria. 2nd edition (Abakaliki: Global Publishing Co. Ltd.
K.J. Bielu, (2021). Applicability of the Doctrine of Covering the Field under the Nigerian Tax Law: Pitfalls in Attorney-General of the Federation v. Attorney-General of Lagos State. Int’l Review of Law & Jurisprudence. 3(3). 167-174.
Kana, A.A. (2021). Vertical Power Sharing in Nigeria's Federal System: Issues, Challenges and Prospects. Int’l Review of Law and Jurisprudence. 3(1).
Kumar, V. and Aahire, A.K. (2024). Revisiting Rousseau's social contract theory through the lens of politico-moral philosophy. Int. J Political Sci Governance. 6(1). 173-176.
Kymlicka, W. & Magda, O. (2002). Can liberal Pluralism Be Exported? Western Political Theory and Ethnic Relations in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lépine, F. (2012). A Journey through the History of Federalism Is Multilevel Governance a Form of Federalism? L’Europe en formation. nº 363 Printemps.
Lermack, P. (2007). The Constitution Is the Social Contract So It Must Be a Contract...Right? A Critique of Originalism as Interpretive Method. William Mitchell Law Review. 33(4). 1403-1445.
Mandaci, N. and Tepeciklio?lu, E.E. (2018). Whither Nigerian Federalism? Federal Arrangements as Conflict Management Devices. Igd Univ Jour Soc Sci Say?. 14. 399-418.
Mengie, L.T. (2016). Federalism as an Instrument for Unity and the Protection of Minorities: A Comparative Overview: Ethiopia, India and the US. Mizan Law Review. 10(2). 265-295.
Nwebo, O.E. (2019). Federalism under the 1999 Constitution: The challenge of restructuring and democratic legitimacy. In Adeola and Jegede (eds.) Governance in Nigeria Post-1999: Revisiting the Democratic ‘New Dawn’ of the Fourth Republic. Pretoria University Law Press (PULP, 2019). 43-63.
Obidimma, A.E. and Obidimma, E.O.C. (2015). Restructuring the Nigerian Federation for Proper Functioning of the Nigerian Federalism. Public Policy and Administration Research. 5(9). 147-157.
Odike, E.A. (2006). Nigeria’s Federalism: A Myth or Reality. Abakaliki Bar Journal, 1(1).
Odike, E.A., Faga, H.P. and Nwakpu, I.W. (2016). Incorporation of Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy in the Constitutions of Emerging Democracies: A Beneficial Wrongdoing or a Democratic Demagoguery? Beijing L. Rev. 7. 267.
Ogene, O.S. (2002). Fashioning the Constitution of the Federal Democratic System: A Comparative Analyses of Nigeria, Australia, Canada and the United States Representative Systems. (Enugu: CIDTAP Press.
Ogunwa, S. A. & Abasilim, U. D. (2024). Democracy, federalism and governance in Nigeria. Journal of Governance and Development. 20(1). 105-127.
Ogunwa, S. A. & Abasilim, U. D. (2024). Democracy, federalism and governance in Nigeria. Journal of Governance and Development. 20(1). 105-127.
Ojo, E.O. (2014). The Military and the Challenge of Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria: Positive Skepticism and Negative Optimism. Journal of Military and Strategic Studies. 15(4). 9-37.
Oliver, P. (2017). Autochthonous Constitutions. In R. Grote, F. Lachenmann & R. Wolfrum, (eds.) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Comparative Constitutional Law (Oxford University Press).
Omoregie, E.B. and Onyeaku, C. (2020). Legal Framework of State Role in Public Safety and Public Order. NILDS Legal Issue Brief. 1(1). 1-4.
Oni, E. and Faluyi, O. (2018). Federalism, Military Legacies and the Restructuring Debate in Contemporary Nigeria. African Journal of Governance and Development. 7(2). 1-23.
Oni, S.O. (2023). Constitutional Autochthony: Nigeria and Ghana Perspectives. International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews. 10(3). 385-395.
Osipitan, T. (2014). An Autochthonous Constitution for Nigeria myth or reality? Lagos: University of Lagos Inaugural Lecture Series, University of Lagos Press.
Osipitan, T. and Amusa, K.O. (2006). The Search for Legitimacy of the 1999 Constitution. N. Tobi (ed.) A Living Judicial Legend: Essays in Honour of Hon. Justice A.G. Karibi Whyte (Lagos: Jericho publishers). 15-30.
Riker, W. (1964). Federalism Origin Operation and Significance. (Boston USA; Little Brown Publishing Co.
Rotimi, A. & Yinka, F. (2015). Introductory Text in Political Science. Omuaran: Landmark University Press.
Rousseau, J.J. (1762). The Social Contract or Principles of Political Right. Translated by G. D. H. Cole (London and Toronto: J.M. Dent and Sons, 1923).
So-oriari, J. and Francis, T.A. (2023). The Impact of Military Rule on Constitutional Development in Nigeria. The Journal of Law and Policy. 3(2). 231-263.
Stotsky, J.G. and Sunley, E.M. (1997). United States. In Ter-Minassian, T. (ed.) Fiscal Federalism in Theory and Practice. (International Monetary Fund). 359-383.
Strijdom, J. (2013). A Political Problem in Inter-human Relations: Autochthony in Ancient Greek and Modern African Thought and Practice. Phronimon. 14(1). 79-92.
Suben, M. (1981). Federal Grants and the Tenth Amendment: Things as They Are and Fiscal Federalism. Fordham L. Rev. 50. 130-154.
Suberu, R. (2019). Nigeria’s Permanent Constitutional Transition: Military Rule, Civilian Instability and ‘True Federalism’ in a Deeply Divided Society. Forum of Federations: Occasional Paper Series, no. 34, Ottawa, Ontario (Canada).
Suberu, R.T. (2022). Ethnic Inequality, the Federal Character Principle, and the Reform of Nigeria’s Presidential Federalism. United Nation University WIDER Working Paper 2022/113. October, 2022. Available at: https://www.wider.unu.edu/sites/default/files/Publications/Working-paper/PDF/wp2022-113-ethnic-inequality-federal-character-principle-reform-Nigeria-presidential-federalism.pdf (Last accessed 14th September, 2024).
Uguru, U., Faga, H.P. & A.D. Obiekwe, (2016). The Role of Innovation in the Economic Development of Nigeria. Int’l J. Innovative Research & Dev. 5(6). 500-518.
Ukwueze, E.R. (2009). Local Government and Fiscal Federalism in Nigeria. Jos Journal of Economics. 4(1). 174-194.
Vande, P.T. (2021). Fiscal Federalism and the Politics of Revenue Allocation in Nigeria. Zamfara Journal of Politics and Development. 1-19.
Watts, R.L. (2008). Comparing Federal Systems. 3rd ed. (Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
Weale, A. (2020). Contractual Constitutions. In Weale, A. (ed.) Modern Social Contract Theory. Oxford University Press. 417-430.
World Bank, (2024). Gross National Income Per Capita 2023, Atlas Method and PPP: World Development Indicators database. 1 July 2024. Available at: https://datacatalogfiles.worldbank.org/ddh-published/0038128/DR0046435/GNIPC.pdf?versionId=2024-07-01T12:43:25.7145590Z (Last accessed 14th September, 2024).
Judicial Authorities
Attorney General of Abia State & 35 ors v. Attorney General of the Federation of Nigeria (2002) 6 NWLR (Pt. 763) 497.
Attorney General of Federation v. Attorney General, Lagos State (2013) 16 NWLR (Pt. 1380) 249 SC
CAN v. INEC (2013) 13 NWLR (Pt.1370) 161 SC
Okotie Eboh v. Ebiowo Manager (2004) 18 NWR (Pt. 905) 242.
Orhium v. F.R.N (2005) 1 NWLR (Pt.906) 59 SC.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Adakole E. Odike, Hemen Philip Faga, Matthew Enenche Ogwuche
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
